Reynolds at­tend­ed the Nor­mal Sing­ing Schools run by J. Hen­ry Sho­wal­ter and J. B. Her­bert (1902-03), Miss­iss­ip­pi Coll­ege (1905-06), Moo­dy Bi­ble In­sti­tute (1907-08), Sie­gel-My­ers Un­i­ver­si­ty Cor­res­pon­dence School of Mu­sic (BM 1918) and the Chi­ca­go Mu­sic­al Coll­ege (1920). In 1942, he re­ceived a MusD de­gree from the South­ern School of Fine Arts in Hous­ton, Tex­as. He was a mem­ber of the Cum­ber­land Pres­by­ter­i­an Church and lat­er the High­land Bap­tist Church in Birm­ing­ham, Al­a­ba­ma. For about a de­cade be­gin­ning around 1905, he was a sing­ing evan­gel­ist un­der the aus­pices of the Miss­iss­ip­pi Bap­tist State Mis­sion Board and the South­ern Bap­tist Home Mis­sion Board. His works in­clude:

• Practical Church Mu­sic, 1923
• The Min­is­try of Mu­sic in Re­li­gion, 1928
• Church Mu­sic, 1935
• The Choir in the Non-Litur­gi­cal Church, 1938
• Music and the Scrip­tures, 1942

1. Jesus Is the Friend You Need
2. Jesus My Lord Is Real to Me
3. Some Sweet Day
4. Will You Come?